Breast Pump Comparison - Medela, Philips, Ameda and First Years

Breast Pump Comparison Chart
NOTE: Comparison chart was created based on available information and features are subject to change. Consult manufacturer for safety information.

Whether you need a breast pump for frequent pumping while you return to work or if it's just for occasional pumping, it's a decision not to take lightly. Electric pumps make it much easier to pump, but can be expensive. This comparison chart helps you find the right pump for you and your baby.

	Medela Pump in Style Advanced Breast Pump with On the Go Tote	Medela Swing Breast Pump	Philips AVENT BPA Free Manual Breast Pump, White	Ameda Purely Yours Ultra Breast Pump	The First Years miPump – Basic
Cost	Approx $280	Approx $150	Approx $40	Approx $299	Approx $80
Automatic / Manual	Automatic and manual	Automatic	Manual	Automatic and manual	Automatic
Frequent Pumping			No, but company states it is clinically proven to be as effective as a hospital grade electric pump with preterm infant deliver.
Power Sources	AC Adapter, battery or manual. Optional car adapter sold separately	AC Adapter with battery option.	None, manual pump	AC adapter, battery or manual	AC adapter, battery
Pumping Technique	Adjustable speed, 2 phase process the mimics actual feeding	2 phase process mimics actual feeding	Manual with patented 5-petal massage cushion. Vacuum mimics actual feeding	Adjustable cycle and suction controls	Quick cycle time, adjustable suction
Warrantee	1 year motor, 90 days on parts	1 year motor, 90 days on parts	1 year limited warrantee	1 year motor, 90 days on parts	90 day limited warrantee
Single or Double	Double	Single	Single	Double	Double, but available in single
Accessories	Travel bag with extra storage, removable PVC-free cooler bag, containers with lids	Breast shield, 2 bottles with caps, drawstring bag.	1 bottle with nipple and lid.	Dual hygiene kit milk collection system; Ultra suede/faux leather tote; Cool 'n carry tote	Fashion tote for transport

Back to Main Page